--- title: How do you trust someone who shouts at you? description: Shouty bosses - how do you trust someone who shouts at you? image: https://www.centreforteams.com/hubfs/alan-sugar%20youre%20fired.png --- [\+ 020 4538 9923](tel:+%20020%204538%209923)[info@centreforteams.com](mailto:info@centreforteams.com) [\+ 44 20 4538 9923](tel:+2045389923)[info@centreforteams.com](mailto:info@centreforteams.com) [![CFT-Nav-Bar-Logo-NEW](https://www.centreforteams.com/hs-fs/hubfs/CFT-Nav-Bar-Logo-NEW.webp?width=414&height=69&name=CFT-Nav-Bar-Logo-NEW.webp "CFT-Nav-Bar-Logo-NEW")](https://www.centreforteams.com/) [![Screenshot\_2024-06-19\_104847-removebg-preview](https://www.centreforteams.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Screenshot_2024-06-19_104847-removebg-preview.png?width=190&height=48&name=Screenshot_2024-06-19_104847-removebg-preview.png "Screenshot_2024-06-19_104847-removebg-preview")](https://www.centreforteams.com/) - [Home](https://www.centreforteams.com) - How We Work - [Adaptable Teams](https://www.centreforteams.com/adaptable-teams) - [Meet The Team](https://www.centreforteams.com/meet-the-team) - Our Solutions - **[Executive Coaching](https://www.centreforteams.com/leadership-coaching)** - [Executive Coaching Programmes](https://www.centreforteams.com/executive-coaching-programmes) - [The Emerging Leaders Programme](https://www.centreforteams.com/strengthening-leadership-capability) - [The Adaptable Team Leaders Programme](https://www.centreforteams.com/the-adaptable-team-leaders-programme) - [Coaching with An Edge](https://www.centreforteams.com/coaching-with-an-edge-programme) - **[Team Coaching](https://www.centreforteams.com/team-coaching)** - [Teamship 360](https://www.centreforteams.com/team-development) - [Adaptable Team Assessment TM](https://www.centreforteams.com/adaptable-team-assessment) - [Bespoke Team Workshops](https://www.centreforteams.com/team-coaching-workshops) - [Leadership Circles and Supervision](https://www.centreforteams.com/leadership-circles-and-supervision) - **[Culture Change](https://www.centreforteams.com/cultural-change)** - [Team Learning Summits](https://www.centreforteams.com/team-learning-summits) - [Partnering and Joint Ventures](https://www.centreforteams.com/partnering-joint-ventures) - [Cultural Change Programmes](https://www.centreforteams.com/cultural-change-programme) - Resources - Expert briefs \>\>\> - [Resilience](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/tag/resilience) - [Trust](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/tag/trust) - [Conflict](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/tag/conflict) - [Fun](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/tag/fun) - [Meaning & Purpose](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/tag/meaning-purpose) - [Failure](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/tag/failure) - [Blog](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog) - [Business Breakfasts](https://www.centreforteams.com/business-breakfasts) - [Case Studies](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/tag/case-studies) - [Podcast](https://www.centreforteams.com/podcast) - [Free White Papers](https://www.centreforteams.com/white-papers-from-centre-for-teams) - [Free Chapter](https://www.centreforteams.com/download-creating-adaptable-team) - [Free Guide](https://www.centreforteams.com/download-teamship-in-a-vuca-environment) - [Start To Thrive](https://www.centreforteams.com/book-a-meeting) [Contact Us](https://www.centreforteams.com/contact-us) [Contact Us](https://www.centreforteams.com/contact-us) - [Home](https://www.centreforteams.com) - How We Work - [Adaptable Teams](https://www.centreforteams.com/adaptable-teams) - [Meet The Team](https://www.centreforteams.com/meet-the-team) - Our Solutions - [Executive Coaching](https://www.centreforteams.com/leadership-coaching) - [Executive Coaching Programmes](https://www.centreforteams.com/executive-coaching-programmes) - [The Emerging Leaders Programme](https://www.centreforteams.com/strengthening-leadership-capability) - [The Adaptable Team Leaders Programme](https://www.centreforteams.com/the-adaptable-team-leaders-open-programme) - [Coaching with An Edge](https://www.centreforteams.com/coaching-with-an-edge-programme) - [Team Coaching](https://www.centreforteams.com/team-coaching) - [Teamship 360](https://www.centreforteams.com/team-development) - [Adaptable Team Assessment TM](https://www.centreforteams.com/adaptable-team-assessment) - [Bespoke Team Workshops](https://www.centreforteams.com/team-coaching-workshops) - [Leadership Circles and Supervision](https://www.centreforteams.com/leadership-circles-and-supervision) - [Culture Change](https://www.centreforteams.com/cultural-change-programme) - [Team Learning Summits](https://www.centreforteams.com/team-learning-summits) - [Partnering and Joint Ventures](https://www.centreforteams.com/partnering-joint-ventures) - [Cultural Change Programmes](https://www.centreforteams.com/cultural-change-programme) - Resources - Expert briefs \>\>\> - [Resilience](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/tag/resilience) - [Trust](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/tag/trust) - [Conflict](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/tag/conflict) - [Fun](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/tag/fun) - [Meaning & Purpose](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/tag/meaning-purpose) - [Failure](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/tag/failure) - [Blog](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog) - [Business Breakfasts](https://www.centreforteams.com/business-breakfasts) - [Case Studies](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/tag/case-studies) - [Podcast](https://www.centreforteams.com/podcast) - [Free White Papers](https://www.centreforteams.com/white-papers-from-centre-for-teams) - [Free Chapter](https://www.centreforteams.com/download-creating-adaptable-team) - [Free Guide](https://www.centreforteams.com/download-teamship-in-a-vuca-environment) - [Start To Thrive](https://www.centreforteams.com/book-a-meeting) - [Terms](https://7628916.hs-sites.com/terms-and-conditions) - [Privacy](https://7628916.hs-sites.com/privacy-policy) - [Cookies](https://7628916.hs-sites.com/cookie-policy) [Contact Us](https://www.centreforteams.com/contact-us) [1 Park Road, Hampton Wick, KT1 4AS, United Kingdom](https://maps.app.goo.gl/zJE3XiNL5MC3qeRz8)[020 3667 9294](tel:%20020%203667%209294)[info@centreforteams.com](mailto:info@centreforteams.com) [Trust](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/tag/trust) # [How do you trust someone who shouts at you?](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/how-do-you-trust-someone-who-shouts-at-you) by [David Paice](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/author/david-paice) 2 min read Jun 19, 2025 ##### Is it better to be feared or loved? How can someone be expected to perform a task diligently if they are coerced through aggression to do so.  Yet it depends on perspective as well. Seen through the eyes of the boss, might it be possible to correlate productivity with shouty-ness?   Academic research into abusive supervision — defined as sustained hostile verbal and nonverbal behaviours by managers (Tepper, 2000) — paints a complex picture. Studies consistently show that aggressive leadership is linked to lower employee satisfaction, higher turnover, and decreased job performance. Critically, one of the most damaged assets in this dynamic is **employee trust**. Research by Mackey et al. (2017) demonstrates that abusive leadership diminishes trust because employees begin to doubt their leader’s intentions and fairness. Without trust, employees may withhold ideas, avoid taking initiative, and feel less committed to the organization.   ##### The beatings will continue until morale improves! However, the picture is not entirely bleak. Some studies suggest that in specific, high-pressure contexts — such as military units or crisis teams — directive or forceful leadership can produce positive short-term outcomes. For example, Schyns and Schilling (2013) argue that while abusive supervision generally undermines trust, in environments where clarity, decisiveness, and authority are valued, certain aggressive behaviours may be interpreted as strength. This can, paradoxically, increase trust in the leader’s competence.   Even in corporate settings, research by Walter et al. (2015) indicates that when a leader’s aggressive behaviour is aimed at defending team goals or confronting poor performance, it can sometimes be reframed by employees as a form of **tough love**. In these cases, followers may retain trust in the leader’s commitment to results, though emotional bonds often weaken.   Still, the long-term risks are significant. Aggressive leadership styles often create a climate of fear where employees engage in impression management, hide mistakes, or disengage emotionally from their work. Over time, this erodes both vertical trust (between leader and team) and horizontal trust (among colleagues), weakening the social fabric of the organisation.   While a “shouty boss” may occasionally drive results or reinforce competence-based trust, research overwhelmingly supports the view that fear-based leadership is a dangerous strategy. Sustained trust — the kind that drives innovation, resilience, and discretionary effort — is far more likely to flourish under leaders who balance accountability with psychological safety and respect.           **References**   Mackey, J. D., Frieder, R. E., Brees, J. R., & Martinko, M. J. (2017). Abusive supervision: A meta-analysis and empirical review. *Journal of Management*, 43(6), 1940–1965. https://doi.org/10.1177/0149206315573997   Schyns, B., & Schilling, J. (2013). How bad are the effects of bad leaders? A meta-analysis of destructive leadership and its outcomes. *The Leadership Quarterly*, 24(1), 138–158. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.leaqua.2012.09.001   Tepper, B. J. (2000). Consequences of abusive supervision. *Academy of Management Journal*, 43(2), 178–190. https://doi.org/10.2307/1556375   Walter, F., Lam, C. F., van der Vegt, G. S., Huang, X., & Miao, Q. (2015). Abusive supervision and subordinate performance: Instrumentality is the key. *Journal of Management*, 41(3), 773–793. https://doi.org/10.1177/0149206311431426   Share this [Share on Twitter](https://twitter.com/share?url=https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/how-do-you-trust-someone-who-shouts-at-you&text=How%20do%20you%20trust%20someone%20who%20shouts%20at%20you) [Share on Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/how-do-you-trust-someone-who-shouts-at-you&t=How%20do%20you%20trust%20someone%20who%20shouts%20at%20you) [Share on LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/how-do-you-trust-someone-who-shouts-at-you&t=How%20do%20you%20trust%20someone%20who%20shouts%20at%20you) Previous story [← The Influence Team Performance Coaching Can Have On Your Organisation](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/team-performance-coaching-influence-your-organisation) Next story [The Missing Link In Senior Team Success: Trust →](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/trust-senior-team-performance-coaching) ### Get Email Notifications ### No Comments Yet Let us know what you think  **Phone:** [+44 20 4538 9923](tel:+020%204538%209923)  **Email:** [info@centreforteams.com](mailto:info@centreforteams.com?subject=Enquiry%20from%20Centre%20for%20Teams%20website) 1 Park Road, Hampton Wick, KT1 4AS, United Kingdom VAT Number: 843986478 Company Number: 5161533 [Join us on Slack](https://www.linkedin.com/company/the-centre-for-teams-limited/) Our Solutions - [Leadership Coaching](https://www.centreforteams.com/leadership-coaching) - [Strengthening Leadership Capability](https://www.centreforteams.com/strengthening-leadership-capability) - [Leadership Circles and Supervision](https://www.centreforteams.com/leadership-circles-and-supervision) - [Team Development](https://www.centreforteams.com/team-development) Our Solutions - [Team Leadership](https://www.centreforteams.com/team-leadership) - [Team Learning Summits](https://www.centreforteams.com/team-learning-summits) - [Partnering & Joint Ventures](https://www.centreforteams.com/partnering-joint-ventures) - [Cultural Change](https://www.centreforteams.com/cultural-change) Resources - [Blog](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog) - [Case Studies](https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/tag/case-studies) - [Podcast](https://www.centreforteams.com/podcast) - [Free Guide](https://www.centreforteams.com/download-creating-adaptable-team) - [Book a Meeting](https://www.centreforteams.com/book-a-meeting) - [FAQ](https://www.centreforteams.com/frequently-asked-questions) - [Teamship in a VUCA Environment](https://www.centreforteams.com/teamship-in-a-vuca-environment) Copyright © 2026 The Centre for Teams Ltd. All rights reserved.  Website by [JDR Group](https://www.jdrgroup.co.uk/) - [Terms](https://7628916.hs-sites.com/terms-and-conditions) - [Privacy](https://7628916.hs-sites.com/privacy-policy) - [Cookies](https://7628916.hs-sites.com/cookie-policy) ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@type" : "BlogPosting", "author" : { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "David Paice", "url" : "https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/author/david-paice" }, "dateModified" : "2025-06-19T10:47:19.711Z", "datePublished" : "2025-06-19T10:43:57.000Z", "headline" : "How do you trust someone who shouts at you?", "image" : [ "https://www.centreforteams.com/hubfs/alan-sugar%20youre%20fired.png" ], "mainEntityOfPage" : { "@id" : "https://www.centreforteams.com/blog/how-do-you-trust-someone-who-shouts-at-you", "@type" : "WebPage" }, "publisher" : { "@type" : "Organization", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://www.centreforteams.com/hubfs/download.png" }, "name" : "Centre for Teams" } } ```