Leadership Development Blog | Importance Of Team Development

How Does Your Boss React to Failure?

Written by David Paice | Sep 3, 2026

If you hear swearing, spitting or even aggression, it suggests failure is not something your boss tolerates too well. Those kinds of responses are unlikely to encourage anyone in the team to take risks or even suggest innovative ideas. Prevention of failure becomes as much a goal as hiding from it when it happens. This does not make the organisation safer, it erodes productivity and slows everyone down.

Psychological safety within teams is often misunderstood as being something nice, soft or permissive. In fact it is none of those things. The researcher Amy Edmondson who coined the term, defines it as a shared belief that the team is safe for interpersonal risk taking. In practical terms, it means people believe they can speak up about errors, concerns, uncertainty and dissent without being punished or humiliated (Edmondson, 1999).

That matters because failure becomes useful only once it becomes discussable. A problem that remains hidden cannot be understood. A mistake that is disguised cannot be corrected. And blaming someone for making mistakes restricts your opportunity for actually resolving the problem.

This is where leadership tone becomes a management tool. The first question after failure should not be, "Who is responsible?" It should be, "What do we know so far?" Then: "What made this more likely? What did we miss? What needs attention now?"

Accountability still matters. But accountability works best when it follows an understanding of how things went wrong: 'I am accountable because this is my role in the team and the process that went wrong was my responsibility but I know how to fix it.' If people believe that speaking honestly will immediately expose them to blame, they will manage the impression of competence rather than the reality of performance. Or as the misconceived business cliche states, 'I don't want well-explained failure, I want unexplainable success. In many cases, the exact opposite is the more desirable option. 

For coaches and team leaders, this creates a useful point of inquiry. What happens in your team when bad news appears? Does the conversation become narrower or broader with everyone inputting their views on what to do? Do people protect themselves, or do they help the group understand what happened?

Failure tests culture because it reveals what the team has really learned about truth. A leader's calm, curious and disciplined first response can turn a painful moment into useful information.

The message is simple for leaders: if you want people to tell you the truth early, make sure they do not regret it when they do.

 

References:

Edmondson, A. C. (1999). Psychological safety and learning behavior in work teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350-383. https://doi.org/10.2307/2666999